Share these talks and lectures with your colleagues
Invite colleaguesWe noted you are experiencing viewing problems
-
Check with your IT department that JWPlatform, JWPlayer and Amazon AWS & CloudFront are not being blocked by your network. The relevant domains are *.jwplatform.com, *.jwpsrv.com, *.jwpcdn.com, jwpltx.com, jwpsrv.a.ssl.fastly.net, *.amazonaws.com and *.cloudfront.net. The relevant ports are 80 and 443.
-
Check the following talk links to see which ones work correctly:
Auto Mode
HTTP Progressive Download Send us your results from the above test links at access@hstalks.com and we will contact you with further advice on troubleshooting your viewing problems. -
No luck yet? More tips for troubleshooting viewing issues
-
Contact HST Support access@hstalks.com
-
Please review our troubleshooting guide for tips and advice on resolving your viewing problems.
-
For additional help, please don't hesitate to contact HST support access@hstalks.com
We hope you have enjoyed this free, full length talk
Printable Handouts
Navigable Slide Index
- Introduction
- Objectives
- What is a systematic review?
- Characteristics of a systematic review
- Many other types of reviews
- Steps in a systematic review
- Managing expectations
- Sources for finding systematic reviews
- Question formulation
- Protocols
- Why use a protocol?
- What should a protocol include?
- PRISMA-P
- Registering your protocol
- Steps in a comprehensive literature search
- Selection of sources
- Developing a search strategy
- Search filters/hedges
- Peer review of the search strategy
- Grey literature
- Citation searching
- Record keeping for systematic reviews
- Record keeping - checklist
- Managing references
- Critical appraisal
- Critical appraisal tools
- Systematic review software
- Summary
- Thank You
- Contact Information
Reflective Questions
-
How have the skills of librarians changed over the past 50 years?
-
What is the future of the university library?
-
What can go wrong in a scoping review?
-
How would you assess the cost of undertaking a systematic reviews and how often would you have one undertaken?
-
How will advances in technology affect community libraries?
-
How should budgets be set for libraries?
Topics Covered
- Systematic review preparation
- Protocols
- Literature search
- Systematic review appraisal
Talk Citation
Sikora, L. (2016, February 29). Introduction to systematic reviews for librarians [Video file]. In The Business & Management Collection, Henry Stewart Talks. Retrieved November 18, 2024, from https://doi.org/10.69645/MINH9678.Export Citation (RIS)
Publication History
Transcript
Please wait while the transcript is being prepared...
0:00
Hello, my name is Lindsey Sikora,
and I'm the Health Sciences
Research Liaison Librarian
at the University of Ottawa
in Ottawa, Ontario, Canada.
My presentation is entitled
Introduction to Systematic
Reviews for Librarians.
And I hope that
this presentation
will help librarians
who are not only new to
doing systematic reviews,
but also provide new tips
and tricks for librarians
who have been doing
systematic reviews for a while.
I should note
that this presentation
for systematic reviews
is not exhaustive
but merely to be used
as a potential guiding tool.
0:30
The purpose of this
presentation is twofold.
Our first objective is to gain
an in-depth understanding
of the systematic review
process from start to finish.
However, that being said,
librarians are not always
involved in all steps
of a systematic review.
This brings us to
our second objective
where we will explore
the key areas
where librarians can
help their researchers
with their systematic
review questions.
0:55
But before we get started,
and for those of you
who may not know exactly
what a systematic review is,
I'd like to outline
what that is.
A systematic review
attempts to gather
all the empirical evidence
that fits pre-specified
eligibility criteria
in order to answer
a specific research question.
This criteria needs
to be very specific
in order to capture
all the relative
primary research studies.
It uses explicit
systematic methods
that are selected with
a view to minimize bias,
thus providing
more reliable findings
from which conclusions
can be drawn
and decisions can be made.
1:33
So what exactly
are the characteristics
of a systematic review?
Well, they include
the following:
A clearly stated
set of objectives
with predefined eligibility
criteria for studies.
It also has an explicit
reproducible methodology.
A systematic search
that attempts to
identify all studies
that would meet
the eligibility criteria.
An assessment of
the validity of the findings
of the included studies,
for example,
through the assessment
of risk of bias.
And lastly, a systematic
presentation and synthesis
of the characteristics
and findings
of those included studies.
Quiz
Disclaimer: This quiz is intended for learning assessment purposes only and does not grant any certification or credit.
If you are interested in getting a certificate for watching the talk, follow the instructions in this talk's Accreditation Information (where available.)