The hard reality: Why private-sector innovation fails inside higher education institutions
Abstract
Institutional transformation in higher education fails not because of technology, but because organisations attempt to introduce solutions into environments that are not ready to support them. This paper presents a bottom-up transformation model developed over five years at a Canadian research university, where traditional change initiatives repeatedly stalled despite strong executive support. Shaped by experience in high-reliability, performance-driven environments outside academia, the model prioritises building the conditions for change — psychological safety, process clarity and iterative development — before deploying solutions. It converts localised improvements into a self-reinforcing flywheel of institutional momentum through five iterative phases: stabilisation, automation, standardisation, integration and repetition. Applied in practice, this approach enabled customer relationship management modernisation without system replacement, data warehouse development from prototype to production in eight months, and a shift from 90 per cent operational workload to 60 per cent development capacity within three years. As operational burden decreases, institutional capacity compounds. The model offers a practical framework for diagnosing cultural resistance, introducing Agile methodologies in nontechnical environments, and building sustainable innovation pipelines — including the use of student talent as a scalable development force. It is transferable to institutions willing to treat operational friction as a strategic risk and approach transformation with discipline and intent. This article is also included in The Business & Management Collection, which can be accessed at https://hstalks.com/business/.
The full article is available to subscribers to the journal.
Author's Biography
Alex Campomanes is Executive Director of Advancement Services at the University of Manitoba, where he has led a five-year transformation redefining how advancement operations build, scale and sustain innovation. Under his leadership, the function evolved from a traditional service model into a data-driven, technology-enabled operation supporting institutional strategy and cross-functional alignment. With more than 25 years of experience across high-performance private-sector environments — including technology, analytics and enterprise operations — Alex brings a systems-orientated approach to institutional transformation. His work focuses on turning operational friction into forward momentum through data discipline, iterative development and bottom-up change. He is known for building internal capability through scalable frameworks, developing student-driven innovation pipelines and applying DevOps-inspired principles in nontechnical environments. His approach challenges conventional models of change by demonstrating that sustainable transformation is driven not by strategy or tools alone, but by the alignment of people, process and systems.
